Monday, January 30, 2012

Sharks and Oxygen: Fact or Fish Story?

Hey there, Shark Defender, we have a quick question for you. Is the following often quoted statement true or false?:
"Seventy percent of the world's oxygen comes from phytoplankton. Sharks, as an apex predator, feed on many of these plankton-eating fish. Slapped with a stigma as people-killers from the popular "Jaws" series, sharks actually save lives — they help provide the world's oxygen supply."
Let's put this one to rest -- forever. The answer is no. There are no scientific studies that link shark populations to the global supply of oxygen.  If we are mistaken, and there is a study, please forward it.

Now we are just as guilty as others in promulgating this shark-oxygen relation (here and here), and for that we apologize.  Mea culpa.

In our list of 10 Things You Can Do To Protect Sharks we list #1 as Educate yourself about the global situation of sharks. On this oxygen issue, we recommend starting your education with Rick Macpherson's recent blog at Deep Sea News and Patric Douglas' blog at Sharkdiver.com.

This is not, however, a repudiation of the fact that sharks maintain overall ocean health. There are many, many studies that link sharks to coral reefs. Also, the removal of large sharks can negatively impact whole ecosystems by, for example, allowing an increase in the abundance of their prey (fewer sharks eat less prey), or influencing prey species through non-lethal means, by causing behavioral changes to prey habitat use, activity level and diet. A science report by the Pew Environment Group titled Sharks:State of the Science is an excellent resource for referencing many of these studies.

35 comments:

Anonymous said...

In university right now, ecology professors are teaching this very idea. You need to understand that much of science deals in theories... I am sure you have heard of "Newtons Theory of Gravitation?" Basically theorizing that gravity exists; it's still just a theory...and "The Theory of Relativity?" Many of these ideas are based on hypothesis as opposed to using empirical discovery, however they are all considered acceptable and people agree that they are as close to the truth as we will ever get.

While I am unaware of one particular study that tests the marine food web collapse theory in terms of proving that the loss of phytoplankton would significantly reduce the world's oxygen (it would make for a great thesis or dissertation for those of us continuing our education in the science field), in theory, it would make sense that if sharks were to disappear, forage fish would proliferate. If there is an overabundance of plankton feeders, the phytoplankton could disappear and the question is, how would it affect the Earth's oxygen supply? The other question is would the marine food web evolve to make up for the disturbance? It could go either way. Notice I use words like "can" and "could." While we can't say, that something is for sure without proving it, on the other hand, we also cannot say that it is emphatically incorrect, again, without testing it. So, just as there may not be a study to prove the theory correct, there also isn't one to prove it wrong.

So, to answer your question, it cannot be answered by a simple yes or no, but we can theorize what will happen one way or another.

Shark Defenders said...

We haven't been able to pinpoint the earliest mention of the sharks-oxygen link, but here is a story from 2004 in National Geographic that links sharks to oxygen, not the other way.

The myth may have started with Erich Ritter, who was in Sharkwater, and has posted on his website: "The protection of sharks is crucial for the balance of the oceans, earth’s main producer of oxygen."

Horizon Charters Guadalupe Cage Diving said...

It was Rob Stewart who spent far too much time in the media fog of Sea Shepherd's Paul Watson a man known, even praised, for his magical ability to pull made up and factually incorrect quotes out of his hindquarters at will.

Rob Stewart used that quote in his film and in most of his media appearances after the fact to sell Sharkwater to the public.

I am sure Rob and Paul never imagined the public would adopt this strange narrative as readily as they did without any question of it's validity.

Anonymous said...

Again, in Universities all around the world, including the U.S., it is being taught that 70% of Earth's oxygen is derived from cyanobacteria (phytoplankton) in the ocean. Will disrupting the marine food web cause an issue for us in terms of obtaining oxygen? Until a model is formed and tested, there is no answer to that question. So, we are left to theorize and unfortunately, the information that is available shows that there likely would be some negative side effect (small or large scale) regarding our oxygen supply.

All scientists agree that cyanobacteria (phytoplankton) were not only responsible for initially supplying the Earth with oxygen, but that they continue to do so. This is not a debate and there is plenty of proof. Here is a wonderful article, one of many, to prove to you that EVERYONE KNOWS that our oxygen comes from the ocean; in this, experts pin pointed when the oxygen was first created, no one is arguing about WHERE it came from. Erich Ritter was not lying or being hyperbolic.

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/10/111019221928.htm

Shark Defenders said...

Thanks for the anonymous comment, Jessica. The oxygen link to sharks is a myth. The study you cite does not even mention sharks.

I encourage you to do a little more research on this, and contact some experts if you must. You'll find you are mistaken.

Shark Defenders said...

As I state in the post, this does not mean that climate change has been debunked or that sharks do not maintain overall ocean health. The cascading affects of losing apex predators are real, but the production of oxygen is not linked whatsoever.

OfficetoOcean said...

Why is it that nobody who comments in favour of this crazy myth ever wants to put their name to it? Simply using the right lingo and sounding the part does not make an expert, just ask the cranks who started spreading this nonsense.

If you're so confident with your arguments, put some ownership on it and debate in public, an unwillingness to do so shows, in my opinion, lack of confidence in what you are saying.

Not one single person with any credibility has backed the Sharks/Oxygen theory. Not a single one.

OfficetoOcean said...

"I think educating people is so important. As you have seen, misinformation spreads quickly and it's not going to help our oceans..."

Indeed.

Ava Amelia said...

Ephedra is definitely the the greatest fat loss dietary supplement available in the market. There isn’t a weight loss pill, that operates superior to Ephedrine. If you wish to obtain Ephedra, kindly visit the Buy Ephedra web-site. deep sea fishing charters Pensacola

Pankaj Singh said...

Nice blog, thank you so much for sharing such amazing content with us. Get the latest Website Designing and Development services in Delhi at Ogen Infosystem.
Website Designing Company

Neha Sharma said...

iso certification in noida
iso certification in delhi
ce certification in delhi
iso 14001 certification in delhi
iso 22000 certification in delhi
ISO Consultant in Delhi
iso certification services in delhi
iso certification in faridabad
ISO 9001 Certification in Noida
website designing services
SEO Service Consultant

Neha Sharma said...

we have provide the best fridge repair service.
fridge repair in faridabad
Videocon Fridge Repair in Faridabad
Whirlpool Fridge Repair in Faridabad
Hitachi Fridge Repair In Faridabad
Washing Machine Repair in Noida
godrej washing machine repair in noida
whirlpool Washing Machine Repair in Noida
IFB washing Machine Repair in Noida
LG Washing Machine Repair in Noida

Neha Sharma said...

we have provide the best ppc service.
ppc company in gurgaon
website designing company in Gurgaon
PPC company in Noida
seo company in gurgaon
PPC company in Mumbai
PPC company in Chandigarh

Neha Sharma said...

Rice Bags Manufacturers
Pouch Manufacturers
wall putty bag manufacturers
fertilizer bag manufacturers
Lyrics with music

Neha Sharma said...

we have provide the best ppc service.
ppc company in gurgaon
website designing company in Gurgaon
PPC company in Noida
seo company in gurgaon
PPC company in Mumbai
PPC company in Chandigarh

Neha Sharma said...

we have provide the best fridge repair service.
fridge repair in faridabad
Videocon Fridge Repair in Faridabad
Whirlpool Fridge Repair in Faridabad
Hitachi Fridge Repair In Faridabad
Washing Machine Repair in Noida
godrej washing machine repair in noida
whirlpool Washing Machine Repair in Noida
IFB washing Machine Repair in Noida
LG Washing Machine Repair in Noida

Neha Sharma said...

we have provide the best fridge repair service.
fridge repair in faridabad
Videocon Fridge Repair in Faridabad
Whirlpool Fridge Repair in Faridabad
Hitachi Fridge Repair In Faridabad
Washing Machine Repair in Noida
godrej washing machine repair in noida
whirlpool Washing Machine Repair in Noida
IFB washing Machine Repair in Noida
LG Washing Machine Repair in Noida

Neha Sharma said...

iso certification in noida
iso certification in delhi
ce certification in delhi
iso 14001 certification in delhi
iso 22000 certification in delhi
ISO Consultant in Delhi
iso certification services in delhi
iso certification in faridabad
ISO 9001 Certification in Noida
website designing services
SEO Service Consultant

harish kalyan said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
oxigen said...

Oxigen BC Private Limited Company is India's Largest CSP Provider, which works in all the states of India to open customer service point of all banks. Such as - sbi, boi, bob, pnb etc.

CSP Apply
CSP Online Application
Online CSP Apply
CSP Registration
CSP Online Application
CSP Provider

bankmitrabc said...

A large number of people, particularly the migrant laborers and factory workers do not have a saving account and even not able to open an account due to lack of valid address and ID proof. As a result they face difficulties to save their earnings in a safe place and look out for solution to send money to their families.

CSP Apply
CSP Online Application
Apply for CSP
Top CSP Provider in India
Apply Online For Bank CSP
Online Money Transfer

jeewangarg said...

Wow!!! It was really an Informational Article which provide me with much Insightful Information. I would like to first thank the author for such an Insightful Content. If someone here is looking for a Website Designing Company in India, then look no further than Jeewangarg.com as we are the Best website designing company in Delhi working in the arena for the last 8 years.
Digital Marketing agency in Delhi

virgoacp said...

Wow!!! A great insightful & informative content on ACP Board. Virgo Group is the largest providers of best in class leading facade materials and more & having years of experience in manufacturing Premium ACP Sheet. We aim to deliver excellence and ensure maximum worth for our clients’ money and so we provide you with the best ACP Sheet Price.

rightselects said...

Thanks for posting such a great post . Right Selects provides its users with the exact information of the “top 10” or “top 5” industry leader of the particular industry. For instance, if you are looking for selecting the best among the array of water purifiers in india , you can visit us for getting the most accurate information about “Top 10 water purifier for home”. Additionally, at right selects, you can have the information on lifestyle products, electronics, appliances, water purifiers, restaurants as well as about the best travel places.

phautecouture said...

I would first like to thank the author for coming up with the insightful information every time. People if you are also looking for the best indian dresses online | buy lehenga online then visit Panache Haute Couture, a leading Indian Designer House for Indian Dresses.

Indian Travel Store said...

Thank You Author!!! You are sharing the very informative and great post. If anyone out there is looking to book manali tour package | Rajasthan Tour Packages then don’t go beyond Indian Travel Store – “Your Trusted Partner in your Travel Journey.”

Pure Digital Online said...

We have worked with many businesses in New Zealand and abroad and we have found that although there has been massive growth in technology, most small to medium sized business owners have been left behind.

Social Media Marketing Company in New Zealand
SEO Company in New Zealand
Website Revamp Services in New Zealand
Graphic Designing Services in New Zealand
Website Design Services in New Zealand
Website Maintenance Services in New Zealand

oxigen said...

Oxigen BC Private Limited Company is India's Largest CSP Provider, which works in all the states of India to open customer service point of all banks. Such as - sbi, boi, bob, pnb etc.

CSP Apply
CSP Online Application
Online CSP Apply
CSP Registration
CSP Online Application
CSP Provider

bankmitrabc said...

A large number of people, particularly the migrant laborers and factory workers do not have a saving account and even not able to open an account due to lack of valid address and ID proof. As a result they face difficulties to save their earnings in a safe place and look out for solution to send money to their families.

Apply CSP
CSP Registration
CSP Provider
Bank CSP
CSP Kisok

sasi said...


I appreciate you for this blog. More informative, thanks for sharing with us.
Salesforce Training in Chennai
salesforce training in bangalore
Salesforce Course in Bangalore
best salesforce training in bangalore
salesforce institute in bangalore
salesforce developer training in bangalore
Python Training in Coimbatore
Angularjs Training in Bangalore
ssalesforce training in marathahalli
salesforce institutes in marathahalli

tike mik said...

You know, most tournaments are multi-day events, so it's not like you can go out there for one day, and whatever happens that day determines the outcome. Most tournaments are three to four days long at the level that I compete at.

sassy pink learn your knots fishing leggings

SBI Kiosk Banking said...

Thanks for sharing such a great information, Here we are India's best service provider of SBI Kiosk Banking.
sbi kiosk banking
sbi kiosk

Indhu said...

Thanks for sharing this informations.
CCNA Course in Coimbatore

CCNA Training Institute in Coimbatore

Java training in coimbatore

Selenium Training in Coimbatore

Software Testing Course in Coimbatore

python training institute in coimbatore

python course in coimbatore

Unknown said...

python course in coimbatore
python training in coimbatore
java course in coimbatore
java training in coimbatore
android course in coimbatore
android training in coimbatore
php course in coimbatore
php training in coimbatore
digital marketing course in coimbatore
digital marketing training in coimbatore
software testing course in coimbatore
software testing training in coimbatore

Unknown said...

python course in coimbatore
java course in coimbatore
python training in coimbatore
java training in coimbatore
php course in coimbatore
php training in coimbatore
android course in coimbatore
android training in coimbatore
datascience course in coimbatore
datascience training in coimbatore
ethical hacking course in coimbatore
ethical hacking training in coimbatore
artificial intelligence course in coimbatore
artificial intelligence training in coimbatore
digital marketing course in coimbatore
digital marketing training in coimbatore
embedded system course in coimbatore
embeddedsystem training in coimbatore

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...